About The Song
John Foster Sings “Tell That Angel I Love Her” – A Heartfelt Tribute to Love and Loss
In a deeply emotional performance on American Idol 2025, John Foster, a rising star from Louisiana, delivered a touching rendition of his original song “Tell That Angel I Love Her.” The song, written in memory of his late friend Maggie Dunn, captured the pain of loss and the enduring love for someone who has passed away. Maggie, tragically lost her life in 2022 alongside her friend Caroline Gill in a devastating car accident. The accident occurred when a police officer, in the midst of a high-speed chase, collided with their vehicle.
Foster’s heartfelt delivery moved both the American Idol judges and the live audience, leaving a lasting impact. His emotional performance showcased his vulnerability and heartfelt dedication to Maggie’s memory. Carrie Underwood praised his performance, particularly for its traditional country style and the tender emotion Foster brought to the song. Luke Bryan noted that the performance demonstrated Foster’s deep connection to his music, while Lionel Richie commended his authenticity, acknowledging how he truly made the audience feel the pain and love behind the song.
The performance was part of the Top 20 episode themed “Songs of Faith,” and Foster’s emotional tribute helped him secure a spot in the Top 14 of the competition.
“Tell That Angel I Love Her” is not just a song; it’s an emotional tribute to a dear friend, making Foster’s performance even more meaningful for those who have experienced loss. His ability to convey such a deep connection to his personal story, while also showcasing his musical talent, makes him a standout contestant in the American Idol competition.
